Marketers today are obsessed with algorithms. They analyze trends, tweak SEO strategies, and optimize for engagement. But what if the real key to success isn’t in the data, but in the story?
In this episode of Speaking to the Best Content Marketing Leaders, we sat down with Molly Ritterbeck, Vice President of Content at Tonal. With a career that began in journalism and evolved into leading content for major fitness and wellness brands, Molly understands that great content isn’t just about metrics, it’s about human connection. Journalists are trained to uncover compelling stories, engage audiences with rich narratives, and deliver trustworthy, well-researched information, skills that every content marketer should adopt. Molly, having experience in both fields, emphasizes this connection through her own journey.
Authenticity Over Algorithms: What Content Marketers Can Learn from Journalists
Many content marketers focus too much on virality and not enough on substance. But in Molly’s experience, the best content marketers are those who think like journalists, asking questions, uncovering stories, and delivering real value.
"I stand by that editorial hires are some of the best hires you can make because their skills are so transferable."
Molly’s transition from journalism to marketing wasn’t easy. She struggled to break into the corporate world but eventually realized that her ability to research, write compelling narratives, and distill complex information into engaging content made her an asset.
She emphasizes that content marketing should not just be about keywords and analytics but about deeply understanding the audience. Journalists excel in asking the right questions, going beyond surface-level information, and providing authentic, credible insights. Instead of focusing solely on keyword optimization, content marketers should craft stories that genuinely engage and inform their audience. In-depth research, careful storytelling, and credibility should be the foundation of any content strategy. By prioritizing authenticity over clickbait and immediate metrics, brands can build long-term trust with their audience.
Why Great Content Teams Focus on Relationships, Not Just Reach
A common mistake companies make is treating content marketing as just another promotional tool. But great content teams don’t exist solely to serve marketing, they drive engagement, brand affinity, and customer retention.
"Organic social in particular really requires consistency and constant fueling of those algorithms."
At Tonal, Molly’s team owns content across multiple touchpoints, from workouts to social media to community engagement. By keeping content production in-house, they ensure consistency, quality, and alignment with the brand’s mission. This approach helps build long-term trust rather than chasing short-term metrics.
She highlights that when content is treated as a mere extension of marketing rather than a core part of the user experience, it loses its effectiveness. For content to drive real impact, it needs to be thoughtful, well-researched, and tailored to audience needs, much like great journalism. A well-structured content team operates not just to serve marketing campaigns but to strengthen the overall brand identity and customer engagement. This differentiation allows content to maintain its integrity while still supporting broader business objectives in a sustainable way.
Creativity Can’t Be Coded - Why Human Storytelling Will Always Matter
With the rise of AI-driven content, many marketers are looking to automation for efficiency. But Molly is clear: while AI is a great tool, it can’t replace the nuance of human storytelling.
"Everything still requires a human touch. The best use cases for AI are where you can create shortcuts, but not where you rely on it for content creation."
At Tonal, they’ve experimented with AI, including their chatbot, Tony, which helps users stay accountable with their workouts. But when it comes to core content, whether fitness programming or brand storytelling, Molly emphasizes the importance of human expertise.
She points out that while AI can streamline processes, it lacks the ability to create emotional depth, originality, and audience trust, key factors that make content compelling. Journalists bring a unique perspective, conducting in-depth research, verifying sources, and weaving narratives that go beyond what AI-generated content can achieve. While AI can be useful in structuring and repurposing content efficiently, it should never be a substitute for the human creativity and insight that build real connections with audiences.
Conclusion: Why Storytelling Will Always Win
The biggest mistake marketers make? Thinking content is about algorithms, not people. While data and SEO have their place, they should serve as tools, not the foundation of your content strategy. At the heart of every successful brand is a story that resonates. Great storytelling will always outperform any SEO trick or engagement hack in the long run because people connect with narratives, not keywords. The brands that truly stand out are those that prioritize authenticity over shortcuts and create content that adds real value to their audience.
As marketing evolves, the most impactful strategies won’t be those that chase fleeting trends, but those that build trust, credibility, and lasting relationships. In a world overflowing with content, genuine storytelling remains the most powerful differentiator.
Past Episodes
Resources for growing your product
